Best Bully Sticks for Puppies of 2026

Natural Farm's odor-free claim is the reason many puppy owners try this bag, and the six-inch size is the reason we keep it in the rotation. The sticks are slow oven-baked and made from grass-fed beef, with no rawhide, which makes the ingredient list easy to understand. We like the six-inch length for a puppy old enough to handle a standard stick: there is enough to hold onto, but it is not the extra-thick slab that suits a full-grown power chewer.

The bag is the other half of the story. This is a bulk purchase, so it suits a multi-dog home or a puppy who gets a chew every day; if your puppy turns out to be indifferent, you are committed to a long supply. The sticks hold up for a decent session, though a focused puppy can make shorter work of them than the phrase long-lasting suggests. We treat the odor-free label as a target rather than a promise.

For a puppy with a sensitive stomach, start with a short session and see how the next day goes; richer chews do not agree with every dog. If your household goes through chews quickly, the bulk format is convenient and the low-odor aim is welcome. If you want a smaller commitment, Bully Bunches is the easier first bag.

A ten-pack of six-inch sticks is the easy answer for a household with more than one dog, or one puppy who goes through chews faster than you can reorder. Mighty Paw makes the bag with a single ingredient, beef pizzle, and no added flavors or preservatives, which keeps the decision simple. We like that the sticks are positioned for puppies and adult dogs alike; you can hand one to the young dog and another to the older dog without buying two separate bags.

The size is the part to think through. Six inches is a lot for a toy-breed puppy, so this bag is better for a medium or large young dog, or a small dog who is already a confident chewer. We also like that the ten-count format is practical for training: you can keep one in the car, one in the treat drawer, and still have a spare.

The recipe is simple and the bag is easy to live with, but the chew time is not the longest in this group. If you need a single bag to cover a puppy and an adult dog, this is the one we grab; if you need a long-lasting chew for a power chewer, Jack&Pup is the better fit.

Extra-thick is not automatically better for a puppy, but it is the right call once a young dog has moved past milk teeth and started chewing with real force. Jack&Pup's six-inch sticks are built for that stage: thick, substantial, and intended for medium and large dogs that like to work a chew. We like the single-ingredient beef recipe and the grass-fed sourcing, because the appeal here is substance rather than a long ingredient list.

The extra thickness is what makes this bag worth considering for an older puppy. A determined chewer gets a long session out of one stick, and the shape holds up better than the thinner puppy sticks that disappear in minutes. Our reservation is that a young dog who is still learning to chew can lose interest in something this dense. This is a chew for the puppy who already tells you what they like.

The value depends on how fast your dog works through a stick; a power chewer earns it back, while a casual chewer may take weeks to finish five. For a young retriever, lab mix, or other sturdy puppy, this is the step-up stick that keeps them busy without turning into a five-minute snack. It is not the bag we choose for a toy-breed puppy, and that is the whole point of having it in the mix.

Cadet sells this as a one-pound bag of small-dog bully sticks, and the weight is the useful number: you are buying a supply, not a fixed count. The sticks are single-ingredient beef pizzle, high in protein and low in fat, with no artificial colors or flavors and no rawhide. We like that for a small-dog household; it is the bag that covers a puppy and an adult dog without a separate purchase.

The lack of a count is the trade-off. You know you have a pound of chews, but not how many pieces or how thick they run until the bag arrives. For a puppy, that means sorting through the bag and choosing a stick that matches the dog in front of you. The one-pound format is practical for a household that already knows it likes bully sticks; it is less useful if you are buying a first chew and want a small trial.

We see this as a straightforward supply for small breeds rather than a puppy-specific chew. If your puppy is already close to adult size, the bag is easy to live with; if you have a toy-breed puppy, the four-inch Best Bully Sticks are the more considered shape. Cadet's strength is simplicity: one ingredient, a useful weight, and no rawhide.

For a multi-dog home with a small puppy and a small adult, this is the bag that quietly does the job. It is not the one we choose when we want a precise count or a puppy-specific length, but it earns its place for everyday supply.

The five-to-eight-inch range is the reason this bag suits a puppy who is ready for a bigger chew: Redbarn's sticks have the substance to last. They are single-ingredient beef pizzle, grain-free and rawhide-free, and the bag is sold by weight so you are paying for chew time rather than a precise count. We like the longer sticks for a medium-breed puppy who has moved beyond the mouthing stage but still needs redirecting.

For a lab, golden, or similarly sized young dog, this is a useful step up from a six-inch standard. The thicker sticks hold up better than the pencil-thin ones, and that is the version to reach for first. A toy-breed puppy may find the longer pieces unwieldy; this is one for the medium-breed end of the puppy range.

The bag is not the first chew we choose for a tiny puppy. What it does well is give a medium-breed puppy a longer project without rawhide, and that is worth a place in the rotation.

Redbarn's range is useful for a puppy who is between sizes, but it is not the most predictable bag in this group. If you want a standard six-inch shape, Bully Bunches is the easier call; if your young dog needs a longer chew, this is the one we reach for.

These are the thinnest sticks in our set, and that is the whole point: a toy-breed puppy or a small senior dog gets a chew it can actually manage. Natural Farm makes the Pixie from beef pizzle sheath, grain-free and high protein, and the six-inch length gives a tiny dog something to hold without the heft of a standard stick. We like the fifty-count bag for short sessions and training rewards; it is a different product from a long-lasting power-chewer chew, and it should be bought that way.

The thin profile is the catch as well as the appeal. A determined puppy can finish one quickly, and the last inch needs to be taken away before it becomes a swallow risk. The sticks are not uniform, either; some arrive closer to scraps than to a proper chew. For a tiny puppy, that is a manageable trade-off if you are using them for short, supervised sessions. For a larger puppy, the standard Bully Bunches is the better shape.

We keep this bag for the small-dog end of the range: a Chihuahua puppy, a young toy breed, or a senior who still wants to chew but cannot handle a thick stick. The fifty-count format makes it easy to keep one in a training pouch and one in the car. It is not the bag we hand to a lab puppy, and it is not the one we choose for a long afternoon alone.

The four-inch length is the reason to look at this bag: it fits a toy-breed puppy's mouth without the awkwardness of a six-inch stick. Best Bully Sticks makes these from grass-fed beef, with no grain and no rawhide, so the recipe is as plain as the shape. We like the shorter stick for a puppy who is still learning to hold a chew with both paws; it is less likely to bonk against the floor or get dropped halfway through.

The bag is sold by weight rather than count, so you get a steady eight ounces of sticks and no promise about how many pieces are inside. That makes this a good choice for a young or small puppy, not a power chewer who needs a long project. For a larger puppy, the six-inch Bully Bunches is the better size.

The natural scent is the part we cannot ignore. This is a beef chew, and the bag announces itself when you open it; if odor is a dealbreaker, a low-odor option is worth the switch. For a small puppy and a household that can live with the smell, the four-inch shape is worth considering. It is also a useful bag to keep in a training pouch, because the shorter length is easy to break into a quick session.