Toys & Chews

Best Dog Toys of 2026

The toughest dog toy on the shelf is usually the one your dog ignores. Toys built to survive a serious chewer tend to be too hard or too dull to hold a dog's attention past the first sniff, and the ones dogs fall for are often in pieces by Thursday. That chew-resistance-versus-engagement tradeoff is what makes this category harder than it looks. Get it right and one toy does two jobs: it occupies a bored dog on a rainy Tuesday and keeps the couch legs out of his mouth.

I keep a basket by the back door, and over the last four months my two dogs — a 75-pound lab mix who chews to destroy and a small senior terrier with strong opinions — have worked through 18 toys from it. The ones picked up unprompted on day one were rarely the ones still intact in week six. Nobody warns you that chew-resistance labels are calibrated to chewing style, not dog size, so the wrong label on the right toy sends you home with something your dog won't touch. The picks below earned their permanent spot in that basket.

1

Chuckit! Ultra Ball 2-Pack

Top Pick
Chuckit! Ultra Ball 2-Pack

Everyday fetch

Our Score 9.6/10
Check Price

Worth Noting

  • Not a chew toy; remove after fetch
Size
Medium, 2.5 in
Material
Rubber
Pack Count
2
Breed Range
20-60 lb
Read the full review

A good fetch ball has three jobs: bounce high enough to chase, float if the game reaches water, and survive the trip back in a wet mouth. The Chuckit! Ultra Ball does all three without feeling like a hard lacrosse ball in the hand. The 2.5-inch medium size is the version to start with for dogs in the 20-60 pound range, and the two-pack means one can live in the car while the other stays by the door.

We like the texture for a simple reason: it gives a dog something to grip. The rubber has a little give, so it does not skid out of a smaller mouth, and the bounce is lively enough to turn a short toss into a real chase. On grass, the ball sits up and waits to be grabbed; in water, it floats instead of disappearing. That matters more than any gadget feature because it keeps the game going.

The two-pack is the practical part. Fetch toys get lost, rolled under cars, or left at the park, so a spare is not a luxury. The ball is also compatible with medium Chuckit launchers, which gives it a second life if your arm gets tired. A spare in the bag is the difference between a short game and a full one.

What we appreciate most is how little ceremony the ball requires. It does not need stuffing, batteries, or a treat hidden inside. You pick it up, throw it, wipe it off, and put it away. For a dog that lives for the chase, that simplicity is the whole point.

That is why it is our top pick: the best default for the most common kind of dog play, with a size that suits medium dogs and a two-pack that makes a lost ball less of an event. If your dog needs a job rather than a sprint, the KONG Classic is the better first toy; if fetch is the ritual, start here.

Bottom line: We recommend the Chuckit! Ultra Ball as the best all-around fetch toy for medium dogs: it floats, bounces, and comes with a spare, so a lost ball does not end the game.

2

Chuckit! Classic 26M Launcher

Chuckit! Classic 26M Launcher

Long-distance fetch

Our Score 9.6/10
Check Price

Worth Noting

  • Handle can crack with rough handling
Length
26 in
Includes
One ball
Material
Plastic blend
Ball Size
Medium, 2.5 in
Read the full review

The Chuckit! Classic 26M Launcher removes the two chores that make fetch less fun for the human: bending over for a wet ball and throwing until your shoulder complains. The 26-inch handle gives you leverage, and the scoop end picks the ball up without your hand touching it. It is a simple tool, but it changes how long a game can last.

We like it for medium dogs and medium 2.5-inch balls, which is the same size as the Ultra Ball. The launcher throws farther than a hand toss with less effort, and the bright color makes it easy to spot in grass. It is a tool, not a chew toy, and it belongs with the fetch gear rather than the toy bin.

The included ball is a starter, not the reason to buy. The launcher is the part that earns its place, and it works with the balls you already have if they are the right size. For a dog that wants throw after throw, this is the difference between a short session and a real one.

Bottom line: We recommend the Classic 26M Launcher for anyone whose dog outlasts their throwing arm; it adds distance and saves your back, provided you keep it out of the chew pile.

3

KONG Classic

KONG Classic

Chewing and stuffing

Our Score 9.2/10
Check Price

Worth Noting

  • Large runs smaller than some big dogs expect
  • Not for power chewers
Size
Large
Material
Natural rubber
Breed Size
Large
Treat Filling
Hollow center
Read the full review

The hollow center is the whole idea. Stuff kibble, peanut butter, or a frozen mix inside the KONG Classic and a dog has to work for the reward, which is exactly the kind of job that makes a chew toy more than a chew toy. The natural rubber has an erratic bounce, so it also works for a game of chase, but the filling is what earns it a place in the toy box.

We like the large for most big dogs because it gives them something to hold with both paws. The rubber has enough give to be satisfying without feeling like a brick, and the shape is simple, which is why it works: there is no mechanism to break. It is a classic for a reason, and the reason is not complicated.

The other thing we appreciate is the routine. A stuffed KONG gives a dog a project during crate time, after a walk, or when the house needs a quiet hour. Rinse the hollow center, let it dry, and it is ready for the next filling. That is a lot of use from a simple red rubber shape.

Bottom line: We recommend the KONG Classic for average chewers and crate-time enrichment: stuff it, freeze it, and a big dog gets a job that outlasts a treat.

4

Outward Hound Hide-A-Squirrel

Outward Hound Hide-A-Squirrel

Puzzle play

Our Score 9.2/10
Check Price

Worth Noting

  • Plush trunk can tear during enthusiastic play
  • Squirrels can be small for large dogs
Size
X-Large
Material
Polyester
Toy Type
Puzzle
Squeaky Squirrels
6
Read the full review

The fun starts when a dog noses into the plush trunk and comes out with a squirrel. The Hide-A-Squirrel is a puzzle and a plush toy in one, and that combination is why we keep it in the rotation for dogs that like to hunt, not just chase. Six squeaky squirrels give a dog plenty to find, and the trunk gives you a place to put them back.

We like it best for gentle players. The plush is soft, the squirrels are light, and the hide-and-seek loop is more engaging than a plain squeaky toy. A dog that likes to pull, nuzzle, and carry will get a lot out of it; a dedicated chewer is better served by a rubber toy. That is a buyer boundary, not a knock on the design.

The extra squirrels are sold separately, which is a small thing until one disappears under the couch. We appreciate that the set gives a dog a sequence of actions—find, pull, squeak, repeat—rather than one burst of noise. For a dog that needs a brain game more than a sprint, this is the pick.

Bottom line: We recommend the Hide-A-Squirrel for gentle dogs that like to search and carry; it turns a plush toy into a puzzle, but it is not a chew toy for a power chewer.

5

Benebone Wishbone

Benebone Wishbone

Power chewers

Our Score 9.0/10
Check Price

Worth Noting

  • Nylon can wear down under determined chewing
Size
Medium
Shape
Wishbone
Flavor
Real bacon
Material
Nylon
Read the full review

The Benebone Wishbone has a heft that tells you it is not a plush toy in disguise. The dense nylon and curved shape give a dog a paw-friendly grip, and the real bacon flavor is the part that gets the nose working before the mouth does. It is designed for the dog that settles in and works a chew rather than the one that wants a quick chase.

We like the wishbone shape because it gives a dog two ends to work and a natural place to hold it. The medium is a good fit for a lot of dogs, and the bacon scent does the work of getting a hesitant chewer interested. It is a toy that asks for a dog's attention rather than a quick snap.

The result is a chew that earns its keep for the right dog. It is not a soft toy you leave in the crate and forget; it is a project for a dog that likes to gnaw. We start with the medium for a moderate chewer and size up if your dog is used to bigger chews. For the dog that destroys plush in minutes, this is the kind of outlet worth trying.

Bottom line: We recommend the Benebone Wishbone for dogs that settle in and chew, especially power chewers who need a denser outlet than rubber.

6

KIPRITII 25-Pack Toy Set

KIPRITII 25-Pack Toy Set

Puppy starter set

Our Score 9.0/10
Check Price

Worth Noting

  • Too small for dogs over 35 lb
  • Plush and rope pieces not for heavy chewers
Toy Type
Mixed set
Materials
Cotton and rubber
Toy Count
25
Breed Size
Up to 35 lb
Read the full review

The arithmetic of a 25-piece set is hard to ignore: rope toys, plush toys, rubber chews, treat balls, squeaky balls, and a flying disc in one box. The KIPRITII set is aimed at puppies and small-to-medium dogs up to 35 pounds, and that is the right way to treat it: as a starter kit that gives a young dog variety without committing to one expensive toy.

We like the mix for teething puppies because it changes texture and sound from one toy to the next. A rope for tug, a soft toy for carrying, a rubber chew for gnawing, and a ball for chasing cover more of a puppy's day than another plush animal. The toys are not oversized, which is the point for a small mouth.

For a puppy, the value is in having a different toy for every mood: something to tug, something to carry, something to chase. We keep the soft pieces for supervised play and put the tougher rubber pieces in the regular rotation. That is how the set makes sense.

The set works best as a rotating starter box: put out a few pieces, keep the rest in a closet, and swap them when the puppy needs a new texture. That is how a young dog gets variety without a floor covered in toys. For a new puppy or a small dog, that is a fair trade.

Bottom line: We recommend the KIPRITII 25-Pack as a budget starter set for puppies and small dogs, with the caveat that the pieces are not built for power chewers.

7

Snuggle Puppy Heartbeat Toy

Snuggle Puppy Heartbeat Toy

New puppy nights

Our Score 9.0/10
Check Price

Worth Noting

  • Heartbeat unit can be finicky
  • Replacement heat packs add ongoing cost
Size
Medium
Heartbeat
Battery-powered
Heat Pack
Single-use
Breed Range
25-70 lb
Read the full review

The first night in a new crate is the moment the Snuggle Puppy is built for. The plush toy has a battery-powered heartbeat and a pouch for a single-use heat pack, so a puppy gets something warm and rhythmic to settle against. The medium size is meant for dogs in the 25-70 pound range, which makes it a better fit for a young retriever or shepherd than a toy-breed puppy.

We like the idea because it gives a puppy a ritual rather than a random toy. The heartbeat unit goes into the belly pouch, the heat pack warms the surface, and the plush is soft enough to cuddle. It is a comfort object for crate time and bedtime, not a training shortcut.

The setup is simple enough to do one-handed: press the heartbeat button, slide the unit into the pouch, and add the heat pack if you want warmth. We like that the heartbeat can be switched off once the puppy settles, so the toy can become a plain cuddle object. The plush is soft, and the size gives a puppy something substantial to lean against.

For a new puppy, that combination is worth trying before the first night, not after a week of broken sleep. It is a comfort tool, not a chew toy, and it works best as part of a crate routine. If your puppy needs something to gnaw, add a KONG; if your puppy needs something to lean on, this is the pick.

Bottom line: We recommend the Snuggle Puppy for a puppy's first nights in a crate: the heartbeat and warmth give a young dog something to settle against, as long as you budget for refills.

8

Multipet Lamb Chop

Multipet Lamb Chop

Gentle plush play

Our Score 9.0/10
Check Price

Worth Noting

  • Stuffing can come out quickly with determined play
  • Too small for large dogs
Size
10 in
Material
Plush
Squeakers
5
Breed Size
Small to medium
Read the full review

Five squeakers in a ten-inch plush lamb is a lot of incentive for a small dog. The Multipet Lamb Chop is soft, floppy, and easy to carry, and the multiple squeakers mean the toy keeps making noise even after a dog has worked over one end. It is the kind of toy a dog drags from room to room rather than leaves in the basket.

We like it for the dogs that treat toys like companions. The plush exterior is gentle in the mouth, the size suits small and medium dogs, and the lamb shape gives a dog something to grab by the leg or the head. It is a cuddle-and-squeak toy, not a chew project, and that is how we choose it.

The squeakers are the main event. With five of them, the toy stays interesting longer than a single-squeak plush, and the sound is distributed enough that a dog has to work around the body to find the next one. We appreciate that for a dog that gets bored with a toy once it stops making noise.

This is the toy we bring out for a gentle game, a cuddle on the couch, or a dog that likes to carry something soft. If that is your dog, Lamb Chop earns the spot; if not, a rubber chew is the better buy. It is a simple pleasure, and sometimes that is exactly what a toy box needs.

Bottom line: We recommend Lamb Chop for gentle players that love a soft, squeaky companion; it is a cuddle toy, not a chew toy, and small dogs get the most from it.

9

KONG Flyer

KONG Flyer

Flying disc fetch

Our Score 8.8/10
Check Price

Worth Noting

  • Heavy and floppy for long-distance flight
  • Not chew-proof
Size
Large
Material
Natural rubber
Toy Type
Flying disc
Breed Size
Large
Read the full review

A rubber disc is a different animal from a hard plastic frisbee. The KONG Flyer has enough give to be easy on a dog's mouth, and its rebound means a missed catch can turn into a second chance instead of a dead stop. We like it for dogs that are learning to catch or that need a softer disc than the real thing. The soft edge also makes it less intimidating for a dog that flinches at a hard disc.

We use it for short, playful throws and for dogs that are still learning to track a disc. The rubber is soft enough to catch and tough enough for a casual game, and the red color is easy to see in grass. It is a yard toy, not a competition disc, and that is how we choose it.

The size is worth checking before you order. The large disc is a good match for medium and large dogs, but a smaller dog may have to work harder to carry it. It is a fun change of pace for a ball-obsessed dog, and a good first disc for a dog that is still learning the game.

Bottom line: We recommend the KONG Flyer for casual yard fetch with a softer disc; it is easy on the mouth, but it is not a long-distance flyer or a chew toy.

How We Tested 18 Dog Toys, and What Actually Survived

We narrowed the field by dog rather than by brand. Anything with a loose plastic squeaker behind a single seam, anything small enough to disappear down a 75-pound dog's throat, and anything stuffed with material that clumps when it gets wet got cut before testing started. From there we filtered by size range, price, and the chew style each package claimed to suit, landing on 18 toys that spanned plush comfort toys (a couple with heartbeat inserts), rubber chews, rope tugs, and treat-dispensing puzzles.

Testing ran for four months in the places toys actually live: the living room rug during work calls, the backyard for fetch and tug, the kitchen floor after dinner, and a long stretch of rainy days when indoor play was the only option. On day one we put all 18 out at once and simply watched which ones got picked first, then rotated a few at a time so nothing went stale. Every toy spent time with both dogs, which is how we separated chew suitability from size: a toy the lab mix gutted in an hour sometimes held up fine in the terrier's mouth for weeks, and the other way around.

We weighed each toy before and after play to see how much material actually came off, checked seams after every session, and noted whether squeakers survived or were surgically removed in the first ten minutes. Fabric toys went through the washing machine twice to see if they came out recognizable, and we tracked how many weeks each one lasted so we could divide price by use — a cheap toy destroyed in an afternoon is worse value than a pricier one still going in month three. The winners weren't the toys that stayed pristine. They were the ones the dogs still dragged out of the basket after the novelty wore off.

How to Choose Dog Toys

Start with the play style

A fetch dog needs a toy that bounces, floats, and survives a wet mouth; a chewer needs a dense material and a size that cannot be swallowed; a puzzle dog needs a job. We keep one toy from each category rather than a basket of near-duplicates. The Chuckit! Ultra Ball is our fetch default, the KONG Classic is the chew-and-stuff default, and the Hide-A-Squirrel covers the search-and-solve mood. If you have a puppy, add a comfort object like the Snuggle Puppy for crate time.

Size the toy to the mouth

Breed labels are a starting point, not a measurement. A toy should be small enough for your dog to carry but too large to swallow; if it disappears behind the teeth, size up. The Chuckit! Ultra Ball is 2.5 inches and aimed at 20-60 pound dogs, while the KONG Classic large can feel smaller in a big mouth than the name suggests. Check the listed dimensions against your dog's current chews rather than assuming the word large does the work.

Match the material to the chew strength

Rubber has give, nylon is denser, and plush is for gentle mouths. None of these is indestructible, and the toy that suits a power chewer is usually the wrong toy for a dog that likes to carry and cuddle. The Benebone Wishbone is the denser option here; Lamb Chop is the soft one. Supervise the first few sessions, and remove anything that develops a crack, a tear, or a loose squeaker. A toy that is coming apart is no longer a toy.

Plan for water, dirt, and replacement parts

Fetch gets messy, so check whether a toy floats and whether it can be rinsed. The Chuckit! Ultra Ball is the water-friendly pick here; the KONG Flyer is not water resistant, and plush toys should stay indoors. Replacement parts also change the real cost: the Hide-A-Squirrel's squirrels are sold separately, and the Snuggle Puppy uses single-use heat packs. Buy the consumables you will actually use, or choose a toy that does not depend on them.

Frequently Asked Questions

Final Verdict

Our default for a dog that loves fetch is the Chuckit! Ultra Ball. It is the rare fetch toy that floats, bounces, and comes with a spare, and it suits the broad middle of medium dogs.

If your dog prefers to work for a treat, choose the KONG Classic instead; the hollow center turns a chew session into a job. Those two cover the most common dog-toy needs, and the rest of the list is there when your dog's play style calls for something more specific.