Milk-Bone MaroSnacks
Top PickWhat We Like
- Ten calories a biscuit keeps rewards cheap
- Cost per treat is among the lowest here
- Firm enough to carry loose in a pocket
Worth Noting
- Firm biscuits need breaking for toy and senior dogs
- Texture
- Crunchy outside, meaty inside
- Dog Size
- Small
- Canister Size
- 40 oz
- Calories Per Treat
- 10
Read the full review
Ten calories is the number that decides this one for us. A reward that small means you can pay a dog for every good decision in a session — the sit, the wait, the loose-leash step — without turning a training habit into a weight problem, and without breaking a biscuit in half with your thumbnail while the dog loses focus.
The build is why we keep buying them: a firm biscuit shell around a marrow center, so there's a crunch and then something meaty behind it. Dogs notice the difference. It's a loud enough payoff to pull attention back in a noisy room, and small enough that a dog isn't still working on it when you want the next repetition. For crate training, where the reward has to arrive fast and disappear faster, that combination is close to ideal.
The 40-ounce canister is the other half of the case. Two dogs on a daily habit won't finish it quickly, the cost per biscuit is among the lowest here, and it lives on a shelf rather than in a drawer. Keep the lid tight: once these sit open they go dusty and crumbly at the bottom of the can, which is a storage problem a jar solves rather than a reason to avoid them.
The trade is hardness. These are firm little biscuits, and a toy breed, a puppy, or a dog with a few missing teeth may need them snapped in two first. If that's your household, the Soft & Chewy canister below does the same job without the crunch.
Bottom line: We recommend the MaroSnacks as the default training treat: ten calories a biscuit, sold by the big canister, and firm enough to ride in a pocket.